Exercising with Pain: Should You or Shouldn't You?

Jon Maneen • October 10, 2023

Thinking about pushing through that painful area again?

So, you've got this burning question: "Should I exercise if I'm in pain?"


Straight off the bat, it sounds like a no-go, right? But like a lot of things in the physical therapy world, it's not so black and white. It often comes down to two words:


"It depends."

There's a huge spectrum of factors to consider before deciding whether to hit the gym or take a rain check. Chief among these are the nature of your injury and how fresh that injury is. Let's dive into a few examples to give you some clarity.

Scenario 1: Meet our spirited high school soccer star who just sprained her ankle three days ago. It's still a bit puffy and there's some not-so-pretty bruising. She's itching to get back on the field, but she's limping more than walking.

Our Take: Keep exercise PAIN-FREE...for now. Sure, she can gently test the limits during range of motion restoration without causing pain, but absolutely no pushing through it. High-impact activities (running, jumping, cutting)? Bench those until her ankle's swelling reduces and her walk's back to normal. Restore motion, improve stability, progressive plyometric training. Oh and most importantly, none of this "you can't play", "now you can play". Practice participation should be progressed throughout rehab. 

Scenario 2: Picture a 42-year-old supermom. She's been battling on-and-off low back pain for 15 years. She's so wary of bending over, fearing it might flare up. All she dreams of is playing with her kiddos and sneaking in a workout without always second-guessing her abilities.

Our Take: First things first, let's ease the pain. Then, it's about rebuilding strength and mobility. 


It's a two-step dance:


1) Calm stuff down. 


2) Build stuff back up. 


Start with regaining pain-free movement, then confidently add training to ensure the pain doesn't stage a comeback.

Scenario 3: We have a 29-year-old gym enthusiast who's been tolerating an aching shoulder for about 9 months. While he persists with his workouts, cranking up the intensity only seems to amplify the discomfort.

Our Take: This sounds like TENDINOSIS (think long-term tendinitis). Our advice? Dive into physical therapy to address any off-kilter mechanics. He doesn't need to ditch exercise, but tweaking his routine using a certain "pain scale" is a smart move.

"Oh, what's this pain scale?" I hear you ask. Great question! Let me show you.

Stoplight of pain

We introduce this scale to ALL our patients, be it for a sprained ankle, a back issue, or an annoying shoulder. Timing is key: We show it when it'll be most impactful. Our ultimate goal is to keep you moving and grooving while on the mend.

Every individual is unique, but these three cases give a snapshot of the diverse situations we often encounter. Whatever your situation, remember: it's about making informed choices and listening to your internal notifications!

Recent Blog Post

Shoulder Rehab
July 5, 2026
Learn how CrossFit shoulder injury treatment speeds recovery, reduces pain, and helps athletes return stronger with sport-specific, surgical-free care in CT.
June 28, 2026
Follow a 14-day runner injury roadmap with pain rules, PT timing, and safe cross-training tips plus physical therapy for runners to heal smart
June 21, 2026
Learn how post-concussion rehabilitation helps competitive athletes restore balance, vision, and endurance to return to sport safely and confidently without setbacks
Golf Swing Injury
June 21, 2026
Learn golf swing injury treatment strategies to reduce pain, rebuild strength, and return to play confidently with 1:1 hands-on care in Central Connecticut.
sports rehab
June 14, 2026
Rebuild athletic development after an injury setback with sport-specific rehab and performance training for a safe return to play without surgery or meds.
Show More
Shoulder Rehab
July 5, 2026
Learn how CrossFit shoulder injury treatment speeds recovery, reduces pain, and helps athletes return stronger with sport-specific, surgical-free care in CT.
June 28, 2026
Follow a 14-day runner injury roadmap with pain rules, PT timing, and safe cross-training tips plus physical therapy for runners to heal smart
June 21, 2026
Learn how post-concussion rehabilitation helps competitive athletes restore balance, vision, and endurance to return to sport safely and confidently without setbacks
Golf Swing Injury
June 21, 2026
Learn golf swing injury treatment strategies to reduce pain, rebuild strength, and return to play confidently with 1:1 hands-on care in Central Connecticut.
sports rehab
June 14, 2026
Rebuild athletic development after an injury setback with sport-specific rehab and performance training for a safe return to play without surgery or meds.
Sports Injury Therapy
June 7, 2026
Learn what to do after a season-ending injury and how high school sports injury therapy helps athletes regain strength, confidence, and return safely.
Runners
May 31, 2026
Learn how physical therapy for runners improves mechanics, builds strength, and supports lasting recovery so you can train consistently and avoid setbacks.
injured runner
By Jon Maneen May 23, 2026
Learn the warning signs your runner injury rehabilitation is stalling, plus practical steps to reset your plan and get back to running stronger.
basketball player lying down
By Jon Maneen May 16, 2026
Learn when to transition to basketball injury rehabilitation that mirrors game demands, rebuilds confidence, and supports a safe return to play without setbacks.
By Jon Maneen May 15, 2026
Learn the best recovery strategies after Murph, including sleep, hydration, soreness management, and when CrossFit athletes should see a PT.