Exercising with Pain: Should You or Shouldn't You?

Jon Maneen • October 10, 2023

Thinking about pushing through that painful area again?

So, you've got this burning question: "Should I exercise if I'm in pain?"


Straight off the bat, it sounds like a no-go, right? But like a lot of things in the physical therapy world, it's not so black and white. It often comes down to two words:


"It depends."

There's a huge spectrum of factors to consider before deciding whether to hit the gym or take a rain check. Chief among these are the nature of your injury and how fresh that injury is. Let's dive into a few examples to give you some clarity.

Scenario 1: Meet our spirited high school soccer star who just sprained her ankle three days ago. It's still a bit puffy and there's some not-so-pretty bruising. She's itching to get back on the field, but she's limping more than walking.

Our Take: Keep exercise PAIN-FREE...for now. Sure, she can gently test the limits during range of motion restoration without causing pain, but absolutely no pushing through it. High-impact activities (running, jumping, cutting)? Bench those until her ankle's swelling reduces and her walk's back to normal. Restore motion, improve stability, progressive plyometric training. Oh and most importantly, none of this "you can't play", "now you can play". Practice participation should be progressed throughout rehab. 

Scenario 2: Picture a 42-year-old supermom. She's been battling on-and-off low back pain for 15 years. She's so wary of bending over, fearing it might flare up. All she dreams of is playing with her kiddos and sneaking in a workout without always second-guessing her abilities.

Our Take: First things first, let's ease the pain. Then, it's about rebuilding strength and mobility. 


It's a two-step dance:


1) Calm stuff down. 


2) Build stuff back up. 


Start with regaining pain-free movement, then confidently add training to ensure the pain doesn't stage a comeback.

Scenario 3: We have a 29-year-old gym enthusiast who's been tolerating an aching shoulder for about 9 months. While he persists with his workouts, cranking up the intensity only seems to amplify the discomfort.

Our Take: This sounds like TENDINOSIS (think long-term tendinitis). Our advice? Dive into physical therapy to address any off-kilter mechanics. He doesn't need to ditch exercise, but tweaking his routine using a certain "pain scale" is a smart move.

"Oh, what's this pain scale?" I hear you ask. Great question! Let me show you.

Stoplight of pain

We introduce this scale to ALL our patients, be it for a sprained ankle, a back issue, or an annoying shoulder. Timing is key: We show it when it'll be most impactful. Our ultimate goal is to keep you moving and grooving while on the mend.

Every individual is unique, but these three cases give a snapshot of the diverse situations we often encounter. Whatever your situation, remember: it's about making informed choices and listening to your internal notifications!

Recent Blog Post

By Jon Maneen April 15, 2025
Running is a high-impact activity that requires strength, mobility, and proper mechanics to help prevent the occurrence of injuries and improve performance. While many runners focus solely on mileage, incorporating strength and mobility exercises into your routine can help enhance endurance, efficiency, and your resilience. At Rebound Performance PT , we specialize in helping runners stay strong, mobile, and injury-free. Below, we share the best physical therapist-approved strength and mobility exercises tailored for runners.
A woman is running on a brick path in a park.
By Jon Maneen April 15, 2025
Learn about common running injuries and how physical therapy helps in recovery. Get expert care with Rebound Performance PT.
A man is lifting a barbell in a gym.
By Office Admin March 17, 2025
Want to train harder and smarter without injuries? Discover how physical therapy helps CrossFit athletes improve mobility, build strength, and recover faster.
A soccer player in a blue jersey is running on the field.
By Office Admin March 17, 2025
Discover the best physical therapy techniques to help young athletes stay injury-free, enhance performance, and recover faster. Learn expert-approved strategies...
By Dennis Brady May 22, 2024
Golf season is in full swing!
Show More
By Jon Maneen April 15, 2025
Running is a high-impact activity that requires strength, mobility, and proper mechanics to help prevent the occurrence of injuries and improve performance. While many runners focus solely on mileage, incorporating strength and mobility exercises into your routine can help enhance endurance, efficiency, and your resilience. At Rebound Performance PT , we specialize in helping runners stay strong, mobile, and injury-free. Below, we share the best physical therapist-approved strength and mobility exercises tailored for runners.
A woman is running on a brick path in a park.
By Jon Maneen April 15, 2025
Learn about common running injuries and how physical therapy helps in recovery. Get expert care with Rebound Performance PT.
A man is lifting a barbell in a gym.
By Office Admin March 17, 2025
Want to train harder and smarter without injuries? Discover how physical therapy helps CrossFit athletes improve mobility, build strength, and recover faster.
A soccer player in a blue jersey is running on the field.
By Office Admin March 17, 2025
Discover the best physical therapy techniques to help young athletes stay injury-free, enhance performance, and recover faster. Learn expert-approved strategies...
By Dennis Brady May 22, 2024
Golf season is in full swing!
By Jon Maneen October 24, 2023
Let's chat about something we all want to avoid but sometimes find ourselves dealing with – injuries.
By Jon Maneen May 10, 2023
Nagging injuries present numerous challenges for active adults and athletes, as they can significantly impact their daily lives and athletic performance. The persistent pain these injuries cause often leads to frustration and de-training. To overcome these challenges, it is crucial to adopt the right approach to recovery, one that not only helps individuals conquer their nagging injuries, but also empowers them with the knowledge to maintain an active lifestyle. In part 1 of this series, we will first address strategies to decrease the likelihood of nagging injuries from occurring. In the next article, we will offer guidance on how to manage your own pain in a step-by-step approach.
By Jon Maneen April 6, 2023
CrossFit is a popular fitness program that involves high-intensity functional movements. As performance physical therapists, we have seen many CrossFit athletes suffer from muscle strains, shoulder dysfunction, patellofemoral and low back pain. Most of the time these injuries are caused from inefficient movement patterns, increased acute or chronic workload or technical error. Rarely are we seeing injuries in CrossFit where athletes can determine it was “one workout” where they suffered an injury. Today, we are going to outline the top 5 strategies for CrossFitters of all levels to stay pain-free.
By Jon Maneen March 31, 2023
Physical therapy is about overcoming obstacles and working your way back to the life you’ve been missing out on. There may be some discomfort along the way, however knowing if what you are experiencing is “good pain” or “bad pain” may help you reach our goals even sooner. In this blog post, we will explore how to measure progress in physical therapy using pain and alternative metrics to understand how you are progressing. Whether you participate in CrossFit , strength training, team sports or running races , Rebound Performance PT can help you measure and achieve success through physical therapy.
By Jon Maneen March 27, 2023
Baseball is a popular sport enjoyed by millions of people worldwide. However, like any physical activity, it comes with its own set of risks and potential injuries due to the nature of the sport. This article will discuss common baseball injuries, sports physical therapy interventions, and strategies to decrease the likelihood of injury and rehabilitation techniques.
More Posts